I have been in this HR game for many years and, regardless of the organization, I always experience employees who are exhausted and anxious. They describe taciturn managers who change expectations without warning, criticize people publicly, withhold information, play favorites or treat people who ask reasonable questions, well, just plain stupid.
What I have noticed is that employees only really want one thing. They want the organization to acknowledge what is happening and do something about it. Sometimes we investigate, document patterns, offer advice and recommend action. Yet inevitably the manager remains untouched because their technical expertise is highly valued, they are lauded for their ability to “get things done” or the results they appear to produce are outstanding. The message from the top is not necessarily that the behavior is acceptable, but that the leader is too valuable, or too well connected to be held fully accountable.
That is the point at which a difficult leadership problem becomes an institutional problem. Employees quickly understand the real deal. They notice when respectful leadership is what is touted in town halls and institutional messages, but abusive behavior is tolerated in practice. They notice when more junior employees are disciplined for relatively minor misconduct while senior leaders are repeatedly coached, protected or quietly excused.
So that, dear readers, is the topic of this week’s Corner Office: what HR can do when bad leaders are allowed to thrive.
I don´t think anyone doubts that bad leadership becomes increasingly more expensive over time. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis published in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology (The role of leadership on employee mental ill‐health through workplace disruption: A systematic review and meta‐analysis of longitudinal research) examined 106 longitudinal studies involving more than 565,000 people. The researchers found that destructive and abusive leadership was consistently associated with stress, burnout and psychological distress over time.
The costs may start out small: silence, lack of challenge to questionable decisions, withholding ideas. Eventually though, the costs become more visible: absence, burnout, grievances, conflict, mistakes, turnover and legal exposure. By the time this happens, the organization starts incurring real costs related to investigating complaints, recruiting replacements and restoring damaged relationships. And if HR has been visibly involved but no action follows, employees may also conclude that HR is ineffective or complicit.
So what should HR realistically do? Well, first, HR should not pretend to possess authority it does not have. One of the greatest risks to HR credibility is pretending that we can guarantee an outcome we do not control. This is not an easy subject because it raises an uncomfortable question about the limits of HR’s authority. HR may have professional expertise, access to workforce data and responsibility for organizational culture, but it usually cannot overrule institutional decisions. But that does not mean HR is powerless. It does mean we must be honest about where our power lies, how we use it and where our responsibility ends.
Employees may reasonably expect HR to stop harmful leadership. But the formal authority to appoint, retain or remove a senior leader may rest with the executive committee or governing board. HR can investigate, advise and recommend but the final decision may belong to someone else. HR should therefore be careful not to say, “We will take care of it,” when what we really mean is, “We will assess the concern and advise the appropriate decision-maker.” Credibility comes from being clear about the process, applying standards consistently, presenting professional advice without fear and refusing to misrepresent who made the final decision.
Outcomes should never be communicated as though it were an HR decision. Nor should HR hide behind vague phrases such as “the organization has decided” if that language creates the impression that the decision emerged from a neutral process. Confidentiality will limit what can be disclosed, however HR can explain the process followed, the standards applied and the boundaries of its authority.
The next thing that HR can do is to turn complaints into evidence of organizational risk. Complaints often run the risk of being understood as personality conflicts, isolated misunderstandings or resistance from employees who are resisting change. HR must therefore move beyond presenting anecdotes and look for patterns. Does this leader have unusually high turnover? Are there recurring complaints about similar behaviors? Do engagement results show low psychological safety or confidence in leadership? Do exit interviews repeatedly mention the same person?
To be clear, a repeated pattern requires a risk response. HR should connect leadership behavior to consequences which cannot be easily ignored. Signals like loss of critical talent, operational errors, delayed decisions, reputational damage or legal exposure, are important because then the full cost of the behavior is visible. A bad leader who appears to deliver results may be doing so by transferring costs elsewhere. For example, HR may be managing repeated complaints, and capable employees may be leaving. These factors should be brought to light and should form part of that leader’s evaluation.
Even when no action is taken against a bad leader, HR can still reduce the opportunity for unchecked harm. One such avenue is to require that important people decisions – recruitment, promotion or performance ratings for example - be documented criteria or panel review. Employees can be also given alternative escalation channels, and skip-level conversations can provide visibility into team conditions.
If a leader has repeatedly demonstrated favoritism, for example, HR can require greater transparency and independent participation in selection decisions. If employees report retaliation, future employment actions involving complainants can receive additional review. If the leader creates confusion through constantly changing instructions, objectives and decisions can be documented more formally. HR may not be able to change the leaders, but it can make it harder for damaging behavior to operate without scrutiny.
One mistake that HR often makes is to bend to requests for coaching in the face of bad leadership. Coaching can help a leader develop self-awareness, improve communication and learn more constructive ways to manage conflict. It is appropriate when the leader recognizes the problem and demonstrates a genuine willingness to change. But coaching won´t fix a leader who apologizes, behaves differently for several weeks and then returns to familiar patterns.
Instead, HR should establish clear expectations, behavioral indicators, support, timelines and consequences. To be honest, not all senior leaders should be people managers. A person can be technically brilliant and still be unsuitable for people leadership. One option may be to redesign the role so that the individual retains valuable technical responsibilities without continuing to supervise employees. But even this option should not become a reward that leaves misconduct unaddressed.
Finally, HR should also take steps to protect employees and pay particular attention to retaliation. It is clearly an HR role to monitor what happens to employees after they raise concerns. Changes in reporting lines, performance assessments, duties, access to meetings and career opportunities should be examined carefully. And also, be careful about confidentiality. An employee may not be entitled to know every detail of an investigation, but they should receive acknowledgement, reasonable updates and confirmation that the process has concluded. Silence creates the impression that nothing happened.
If the conduct threatens employees, violates policy or law, exposes the organization to significant liability, compromises governance or creates a foreseeable risk, HR should document the evidence, advice provided, decisions taken and risks accepted. And do not be afraid to use governance channels if that is what it comes down to.
In closing, I hope that you are able to take away a few strong points: One: Bad leadership is costly. But bad leadership protected by highest echelons of the organization is even more damaging because it teaches employees that organizational standards are conditional and that authority offers protection from accountability. Two: HR credibility does not require HR to be all-powerful. It requires HR to be professionally honest about what it recommended, what it could influence and who ultimately made the decision. And three: HR may not always be able to put a stop to a leader’s bad behavior, but it can investigate rigorously, advise honestly, document clearly, strengthen controls, protect employees, escalate material risks and refuse to misrepresent what has happened.
When a bad leader is allowed to thrive, it’s not good for the organization nor is it good for the employees. And our employees are owed better leaders. HR’s responsibility is to make sure they have good people managers who are genuinely invested in them.
